Our experience building a custom catcher’s gear setup for the player who lives behind the plate.
If you have a young baseball player who loves catching, you already know that this position comes with a little more equipment, a little more responsibility, and a whole lot more time spent getting ready for the next inning.
In our house, catching isn't just an occasional position. It's his primary position across Little League, travel baseball, and summer All-Star baseball. That means his gear gets plenty of use throughout a long season of practices, games, tournaments, and those weekends when you practically live at the ballpark.
When it came time to put together his catcher’s gear, we decided not to buy a traditional boxed set. Instead, we purchased the individual pieces we wanted so we could be more flexible with colors and build a setup that felt right for him.
Here are the three pieces we chose and why buying catcher’s gear individually is worth considering if you have a young backstop of your own.
Quick note: This is our personal gear selection, not a claim that these are the perfect pieces for every player. Fit, comfort, league requirements, and the level of play all matter when choosing protective equipment.
Why We Bought Catcher’s Gear Individually
Buying a complete boxed set is convenient. You get the helmet, chest protector, and leg guards together, and the colors are already coordinated.
But when your child catches regularly, you might want a little more flexibility.
We wanted to select the pieces individually rather than be limited to the colors offered in one complete set. That gave us the freedom to choose the helmet, chest protector, and leg guards separately and create a combination that worked for his baseball gear.
For us, that flexibility was the biggest reason to go this route.
A few things to consider before making the same decision:
- Color selection: Individual pieces can give you more options for coordinating with team colors or creating your own combination.
- Fit comes first: Different pieces may fit differently, so check sizing and try everything together before committing to the setup.
- Your player’s position matters: A child who catches several times a week has different equipment needs from someone who catches occasionally.
- Budget accordingly: Individual pieces can cost more than a boxed set, so compare the total price before deciding.
For our family, having more control over the individual pieces made sense for a player who spends so much of his season behind the plate.
Our Biggest Sizing Lesson: Don't Buy Gear to Grow Into
If there is one thing I wish I had known before ordering our first set of catcher’s gear, it’s this: don't assume sizing up is the best way to get more use out of your purchase.
When our son was 8, we originally bought the next size up, thinking ahead to how quickly kids grow. Once we had the gear in hand and tried it on him, though, it was obvious that it was way too big.
We ended up exchanging both the chest protector and the shin guards for the smallest available options. That made a much bigger difference than we expected when it came to getting the best fit for his size at the time.
It was a good reminder that protective equipment isn't like buying a hoodie a little big so your child can wear it longer. Catcher’s gear needs to fit properly, stay in position, and allow your player to move comfortably behind the plate.
For us, getting the sizing right was more important than trying to stretch our money by purchasing something he might eventually grow into.
My advice to other baseball parents: Measure your player, check the manufacturer's sizing chart for each individual piece, and have your child try on the complete setup before the first game. Have them squat, move side to side, block an imaginary pitch, and get back up. Check that the chest protector covers appropriately and the leg guards stay in position. If something looks oversized or interferes with movement, don't ignore it just because your player might grow into it.
Our experience is also why I recommend looking at the chest protector and leg guards separately rather than assuming one size will work across every component. Each piece needs to fit your player.
The right size today is what matters. You can reassess as they grow.
1. FORCE3 XS3 PRO Catcher’s Helmet
[amazon url="https://amzn.to/4drSMR8" label="Shop the FORCE3 XS3 PRO Catcher’s Helmet on Amazon"]
The catcher’s helmet is one of the most important pieces of equipment in the bag. It needs to fit securely, allow the player to see the field, and be comfortable enough for a full game behind the plate.
We chose the FORCE3 XS3 PRO Catcher’s Helmet in a matte finish as part of our individual gear combination.
When shopping for a youth catcher’s helmet, I recommend paying attention to more than the appearance. Make sure you check the available sizing, adjustability, visibility, ventilation, and how securely the helmet sits on your player's head.
A helmet that shifts around or distracts your player is not a good fit, no matter how great it looks.
What to check before buying:
- Measure your player's head and follow the manufacturer's sizing guidance.
- Make sure the helmet fits securely without uncomfortable pressure points.
- Confirm that the model meets the applicable requirements for your player's league and level of play.
- Inspect the shell, padding, mask, and attachment points regularly.
2. FORCE3 Defender Catcher Chest Protector
[amazon url="https://amzn.to/4eqtX8m" label="Shop the FORCE3 Defender Chest Protector on Amazon"]
The chest protector is another piece we selected separately, which helped us build the color combination we wanted.
This is equipment that deserves careful attention to sizing. A chest protector needs to cover the appropriate areas without interfering with your player's ability to move, squat, throw, or get into position.
Our selected product is the FORCE3 Defender Catcher Chest Protector. The linked listing identifies a 13.5-inch Junior model intended for ages 6–9, so be sure to verify the size and fit range for your own player before ordering.
Age ranges are only a starting point. Your player's measurements and the manufacturer's sizing instructions should guide your choice.
For parents shopping for a catcher who plays multiple times a week, I would also look at how the protector sits when the player is in a catching stance, whether the straps stay secure, and whether the equipment allows comfortable movement.
What to check before buying:
- Measure the torso according to the manufacturer's directions.
- Check coverage while standing and crouching.
- Adjust the straps so the protector stays properly positioned.
- Verify that the exact model meets the required protective standard for your league.
See the FORCE3 Defender Chest Protector on Amazon.
3. FORCE3 Pro Gear Solid State Catcher Shin Guards with DuPont Kevlar
[amazon url="https://amzn.to/4AWgrmy" label="Shop the FORCE3 Solid State Catcher Shin Guards on Amazon"]
Leg guards are another opportunity to customize your setup when you purchase pieces separately.
Catchers need to move constantly: dropping into a blocking position, getting up to make a play, moving laterally, and throwing to bases. Properly fitting leg guards should stay in position without making those movements unnecessarily difficult.
We chose the FORCE3 Pro Gear Solid State Catcher Shin Guards with DuPont Kevlar as the leg-guard component of our setup.
The product listing highlights DuPont Kevlar in its construction. As with any protective equipment, though, material descriptions alone shouldn't determine your purchase. Fit, coverage, construction, and compatibility with the rest of the gear matter just as much.
What to check before buying:
- Measure from the knee to the ankle using the manufacturer's sizing instructions.
- Make sure the knee protection lines up properly when your player squats.
- Check that the straps are secure without restricting movement.
- Have your player practice moving, blocking, and getting up while wearing the complete setup.
See the FORCE3 Solid State Shin Guards on Amazon.
4. The Extra Piece You Don't Want to Forget: Catcher's Throat Guard
[amazon url=" https://amzn.to/4AYUEuG" label="Shop the Force3 Throat Guard on Amazon"]
When you're putting together your own catcher’s gear setup, it's easy to focus on the three big pieces: the helmet, chest protector, and shin guards. But there's another piece you need to account for when playing Little League: the throat guard.
This was an important addition to our setup because Little League requires appropriate throat protection for catchers. Depending on your helmet and mask configuration, you may need a separate guard that attaches to the mask.
It's a small piece of equipment, but it's not something to overlook when you're shopping for your young catcher.
Since we purchased our gear individually, we made sure to account for this additional piece rather than assuming everything we needed would be included with the helmet.
A quick reminder for parents: Check whether your particular helmet and mask configuration meets your league's requirements. Don't assume that a helmet's appearance or an extended mask design automatically satisfies the rules. Confirm the correct setup with your league and the equipment manufacturer, and make sure the guard is securely attached and positioned properly.
If you're building your own catcher’s gear combination instead of purchasing a boxed set, add the throat guard to your shopping checklist before heading to the field.
Find the throat guard we added to our setup on Amazon.
Putting the Three Pieces Together
One of the benefits of buying individual pieces is the freedom to build a setup that works for your player rather than choosing from a limited number of preselected combinations.
Our three selected pieces are:
- Helmet: FORCE3 XS3 PRO Catcher’s Helmet
- Chest protector: FORCE3 Defender Catcher Chest Protector
- Leg guards: FORCE3 Pro Gear Solid State Catcher Shin Guards with DuPont Kevlar
Before purchasing, double-check the exact size, color, and model available through each listing. Don't assume that products from the same brand automatically fit together perfectly. Try the full setup on your player and check that everything stays in place when he moves.
And remember that a helmet, chest protector, and leg guards are not necessarily the only equipment your catcher needs. Depending on the league and level of play, additional protective equipment may be required. Check your league's current rules and the manufacturer's instructions before taking the field.
What I Would Tell Another Baseball Parent Shopping for Catcher’s Gear
If your child has decided that catcher is their position, my biggest advice is to think about how often they will use the equipment.
A player who catches regularly across Little League, travel baseball, and All-Star seasons may spend a significant amount of time in that gear. Comfort, fit, and the ability to move confidently behind the plate deserve just as much consideration as the brand or color.
I would also measure carefully instead of buying a larger size simply to get more seasons out of it. Protective gear needs to fit properly now, not just eventually.
Finally, don't overlook the convenience of being able to replace or change an individual piece. If one component no longer fits or needs replacing, a separately purchased setup may give you more options than replacing an entire boxed set.
For us, choosing each piece individually was a practical way to get the color flexibility we wanted for a kid who catches all season long.
Because when your player loves being behind the plate, the goal is simple: help them feel comfortable, move confidently, and focus on the next pitch.
Frequently Asked Questions About Youth Catcher’s Gear
How do I choose the right size catcher’s gear for my child?
Start with the manufacturer's sizing chart and measurements for each individual piece. Don't rely on age alone, and don't assume the helmet, chest protector, and shin guards will all be the same size.
We learned this firsthand when our son was 8. We initially purchased the next size up, thinking he would grow into it, but the gear was much too big. We ended up exchanging both the chest protector and shin guards for the smallest available options to get the best fit for him.
My biggest advice is to prioritize the fit your child needs now rather than buying oversized equipment for future growth. Have your player try on the complete setup, squat, move around, and practice getting into position before using it in a game.
Should I buy catcher’s gear a size bigger so my child can grow into it?
Based on our experience, I wouldn't recommend it. We tried this with our then-8-year-old and quickly realized that the larger chest protector and shin guards weren't right for him.
Properly fitting protective gear should stay in position and allow your child to move comfortably. Oversized equipment can shift or interfere with movement, so getting the right fit now is more important than trying to extend its useful life.
Recheck sizing as your child grows, and replace or adjust equipment when it no longer fits correctly.
Can I buy the chest protector and shin guards in different sizes?
Yes, individual pieces may be available in different sizes, depending on the manufacturer and model. That flexibility was helpful for us because we needed to exchange both pieces for the smallest available options to get a better fit.
Always follow the sizing instructions for each component and assess how the full setup fits together.
Does Little League require a separate catcher’s throat guard?
Little League requires catchers to have appropriate throat protection. The exact configuration depends on the mask and helmet being used, so check the current rules and confirm that your setup complies. If a separate guard is needed, make sure it's compatible with the mask and properly attached.
What catcher’s gear should I buy first?
If your child catches regularly, start by identifying the required protective equipment and getting the sizing right. For our setup, that meant selecting the helmet, chest protector, and shin guards individually, plus accounting for the required throat guard.
A boxed set can be convenient, but buying individual pieces gives you more flexibility with color selection and sizing. Compare the total cost of both options before deciding.
Disclosure: This post contains Amazon affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. If you purchase through these links, I may earn a commission at no additional cost to you.